The Record · The Cycle
The Cycle
The Cycle is The Record's reading of where the U.S. economy sits in its cycle, built from public data and published as dated snapshots. Below: the states a cycle commonly passes through, and how today's conditions compare with fourteen U.S. cycle peaks since 1929.
I · The Cycle Map
The Cycle Map
The usual order of states Common detours: a correction can re-heat into late expansion; a relief rally can give way to renewed expansion or fail into contraction. States, not a schedule.
- ILate expansionValuations stretched, credit easy, sentiment high, growth still positive but narrowingeuphoria, complacency
- IICorrectionThe Record's reading, Q3 2026Prices fall from their highs, credit spreads begin to widen, the real economy still holdinganxiety, denial
- IIIRelief rallyA rebound inside a weakening backdrop; leading indicators stay softhope, relief
- IVContractionJobs and spending fall, credit losses rise, earnings resetfear, capitulation
- VRebuilding recoveryRecovery led by physical investment: energy, manufacturing, infrastructuredisbelief, caution
- VIReflationDeficits and policy support lift prices faster than outputoptimism returns
- VIIInflation peakInflation re-accelerates and peaks; policy is pushed to respondstrain, impatience
- VIIIFinancial repressionReal rates held down under fiscal constraint; a slow, grinding erosion of real returnsresignation, fatigue
- IXReset and productivity expansionImbalances cleared; growth rebuilt on productivityconfidence, renewal
States a cycle commonly passes through, not a schedule. The phase framework is The Record's own.
Data through August 2026.
II · Where today sits
Conditions at U.S. cycle peaks since 1929, and where today sits
Thirteen NBER peaks plus the March 2000 market peak (standing in for the March 2001 NBER peak). The February 1945 wartime peak is omitted. Today is a reading, not a peak.
Of 18 scored measures, today's reading is the weakest of the sample on 5 and among the three weakest on 11 (2 of them tied).
Each dot is one peak, placed by its reading; right is more exposed.
Showing in every row.
Growth & activity
Real GDP growth into today's reading (+2.2%) sits mid-pack, the 6th slowest of 15. Industrial production growth (+1.4%) is the 3rd slowest, above only Feb 2020 and Jan 1980.
Labor
Unemployment (4.2%) is near the middle of the peak range. Payroll growth (+0.3% over the year) is the slowest at any peak in the sample.
Consumer
The saving rate (4.1%) is the 3rd lowest, behind Dec 2007 and Mar 2000.
Real disposable income per person (+1.1%) is the 4th slowest-growing.
Consumer credit relative to income (21.5%) ties Mar 2000 for 3rd highest, behind Feb 2020 and Dec 2007.
Inequality
The top 1% income share (22.4%, 2024) ties Aug 1929 for 3rd highest, behind Feb 2020 and Dec 2007.
Housing
Housing starts are down 1% on the year, one of the mildest readings in the sample. Most peaks arrived with starts already falling by double digits.
Corporate (context)
Corporate profits relative to GDP (14.5%) are the highest of any column in the sample.
Credit & leverage
Household mortgage and consumer debt relative to GDP (59%) is the 4th highest, well below Dec 2007's 90%.
Margin debt relative to GDP (4.5%) is the 2nd highest, behind Aug 1929.
Fiscal
Gross federal debt (121% of GDP), debt held by the public (97%) and the twelve-month deficit (5.5% of GDP) are each the largest at any peak in the sample.
Trade
The effective tariff rate actually collected (8.2%) is the highest since 1937 in this sample. It is still below the 1929 (12.9%) and 1937 (14.3%) readings.
Liquidity (context)
Federal Reserve credit relative to GDP (20.6%) is the highest in the sample, just above Feb 2020's 19.0%. It reflects a different policy regime from the pre-2008 columns.
Valuation & market
Today's cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio (40.6) is the 2nd highest at any peak in the sample, behind March 2000.
The dividend yield (1.1%) is the lowest.
Corporate equity value relative to GDP (255%) is the highest.
The trailing equity risk premium is below zero (−0.5pp), but four earlier peaks (2000, 1981, 1990, 1969) printed lower.
Robert Shiller's online data, file of October 2026: the cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio as of September 2026; the dividend yield and the equity risk premium as of June 2026.
Rates & policy
The short-term policy rate (3.9%) is near the middle of the peak range. The latest Fed move was a hike (September 2026); the latest move was also a hike at 11 of the 14 earlier columns.
Cycle
The current expansion (78 months and ongoing) is longer than all but four of the expansions that ended at the peaks in this sample.
III · The full comparison table
The full comparison table
Open the full table
| Measure | Aug 1929 | May 1937 | Nov 1948 | Jul 1953 | Aug 1957 | Apr 1960 | Dec 1969 | Nov 1973 | Jan 1980 | Jul 1981 | Jul 1990 | Mar 2000 | Dec 2007 | Feb 2020 | Today |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Growth & activity | |||||||||||||||
| Real GDP growth | +6.7%R | +5.1%A | +3.9%P | +6.8%P | +3.1%P | +2.1%P | +2.0%P | +4.0%P | +1.4%P | +4.3%P | +1.7%P | +4.2%P | +2.1%P | +3.4%P | +2.2%PQ2 2026 |
| Industrial production | +13.2%P | +19.6%P | +1.5%P | +18.3%P | +3.4%P | +1.5%P | +1.8%P | +6.5%P | +0.9%P | +6.5%P | +2.5%P | +4.4%P | +2.2%P | -1.4%P | +1.4%PAug 2026 |
| Labor | |||||||||||||||
| Unemployment rate | 3.2%A | 14.3%A | 3.8%P | 2.6%P | 4.1%P | 5.2%P | 3.5%P | 4.8%P | 6.3%P | 7.2%P | 5.5%P | 4.0%P | 5.0%P | 3.5%P | 4.2%PSep 2026 |
| Employment growth | +2.6%A | +6.7%A | +1.6%P | +5.0%P | +0.9%P | +2.8%P | +2.9%P | +3.9%P | +2.2%P | +2.0%P | +1.6%P | +2.6%P | +0.8%P | +1.5%P | +0.3%PSep 2026 |
| Consumer | |||||||||||||||
| Personal saving rate | 4.7%A | 6.7%A | 9.7%P | 10.9%P | 11.4%P | 8.4%P | 11.8%P | 14.4%P | 9.9%P | 12.3%P | 8.7%P | 3.8%P | 2.4%P | 7.5%P | 4.1%PAug 2026 |
| Real DPI per capita | n/a | +2.8%A | +5.5%P | +2.5%P | +1.3%P | +0.7%P | +2.8%P | +2.2%P | −0.1%P | +2.5%P | +2.0%P | +2.8%P | +0.4%P | +1.7%P | +1.1%PAug 2026 |
| Consumer credit / income | 7.4%A | 8.8%A | 7.8%P | 12.3%P | 14.3%P | 15.4%P | 17.5%P | 18.0%P | 18.1%P | 16.0%P | 18.6%P | 21.5%P | 24.5%P | 25.2%P | 21.5%PAug 2026 |
| Inequality | |||||||||||||||
| Top 1% income share | 22.4%A | 17.1%A | 12.2%A | 9.9%A | 10.2%A | 10.0%A | 10.4%A | 9.2%A | 10.0%A | 10.0%A | 14.3%A | 21.5%A | 23.5%A | 23.6%A | 22.4%A2024 |
| Housing | |||||||||||||||
| Housing starts | −32%A | +9%A | −24%P | −8%P | −8%P | −19%P | −14%P | −29%P | −18%P | −18%P | −18%P | −6%P | −37%P | +38%P | −1%PAug 2026 |
| Corporate (context) | |||||||||||||||
| Corporate profits / GDPcontext, not scored | 10.4%A | 7.6%A | 11.7%P | 10.6%P | 10.3%P | 10.1%P | 8.9%P | 9.2%P | 8.5%P | 7.9%P | 6.8%P | 8.5%P | 10.5%P | 10.4%P | 14.5%PQ2 2026 |
| Credit & leverage | |||||||||||||||
| Household debt / GDP | 24%R | 23%R | 18%P | 25%P | 32%P | 36%P | 39%P | 39%P | 44%P | 42%P | 54%P | 61%P | 90%P | 67%P | 59%PQ2 2026 |
| Margin debt / GDP | 7.5%R | 1.6%A | 0.2%P | 0.5%P | 0.6%P | 0.6%P | 0.8%P | 0.6%P | 0.7%P | 0.6%P | 0.6%P | 3.0%P | 2.4%P | 2.5%P | 4.5%PAug 2026 |
| Fiscal | |||||||||||||||
| Gross federal debt / GDP | 16%A | 44%R | 92%A | 68%A | 57%A | 54%A | 35%P | 32%P | 31%P | 31%P | 54%P | 58%P | 63%P | 107%P | 121%PQ2 2026 |
| Debt held by public / GDP | 15%R | 40%R | 79%A | 56%A | 46%A | 44%A | 27%A | 23%P | 24%P | 24%P | 41%P | 37%P | 35%P | 79%P | 97%PQ2 2026 |
| Federal budget balance / GDP | +0.7%A | −2.4%A | +4.3%A | −1.7%A | +0.7%A | +0.1%A | +0.3%A | −1.0%A | −1.6%A | −2.5%A | −3.7%P | +1.4%P | −1.3%P | −4.9%P | −5.5%P12 mo to Aug 2026 |
| Trade | |||||||||||||||
| Effective tariff rate | 12.9%A | 14.3%A | 5.2%A | 5.2%A | 5.8%A | 6.8%P | 6.2%P | 4.1%P | 2.8%P | 3.4%P | 3.5%P | 1.7%P | 1.4%P | 3.4%P | 8.2%PQ2 2026 |
| Liquidity (context) | |||||||||||||||
| Fed credit / GDPcontext, not scored | 1.3%A | 2.7%A | 8.3%P | 6.5%P | 5.0%P | 4.8%P | 5.5%P | 5.4%P | 4.6%P | 4.1%P | 4.0%P | 5.0%P | 5.7%P | 19.0%P | 20.6%POct 2026; GDP Q2 2026 |
| Valuation & market | |||||||||||||||
| Corporate equities / GDP | n/a | n/a | 34%A | 34%P | 58%P | 63%P | 68%P | 67%P | 37%P | 42%P | 53%P | 163%P | 115%P | 160%P | 255%PQ2 2026 |
| Rates & policy | |||||||||||||||
| Short rate · last Fed move | 5.7% · hikeP | 1.5% · hike (reserve req.)P | 1.5% · hikeP | 2.0% · hikeP | 3.2% · hikeP | 3.9% · hikeP | 9.0% · hikeP | 10.0% · hikeP | 13.8% · hikeP | 19.0% · hikeP | 8.2% · cutP | 5.9% · hikeP | 4.2% · cutP | 1.6% · cutP | 3.9% · hikePOct 2026 |
| Cycle | |||||||||||||||
| Expansion length | 21P | 50P | 37P | 45P | 39P | 24P | 106P | 36P | 58P | 12P | 92P | 108P | 73P | 128P | 78+POct 2026 |
- P: primary series at the peak month or quarter. A: annual or fiscal-year figure. R: rebuilt from a published historical table, such as Census Historical Statistics or Fed Banking and Monetary Statistics.
- Each scored row is ranked by its displayed (rounded) values. Ties share a rank. No ranks are combined across rows.
- Short rate is ranked on the rate level only. The "last move" half of the cell is descriptive.
- 1929 and 1937 consumer credit is on the older NBER definition, which understates it.
- 1929 and 1937 federal debt is roughly 1.5-2.5pp of GDP below the OMB basis.
- The 1937 unemployment rate counts relief workers as unemployed.
- 1953 industrial production is inflated by the 1952 steel strike base.
- The 1929 margin figure uses brokers' loans as a proxy.
IV · Snapshots
Snapshots
V · Corrections
Corrections
Correction, November 2026
Atlanta Residential, September 2026: the 30-year fixed reading said above; the figures beside it show it below its long-run norm.
Correction, November 2026
Atlanta Residential, September 2026: the 30-year weekly reading said above; the figures beside it show it below its long-run norm.
Correction, November 2026
Atlanta Residential, June 2026: the 30-year monthly reading said above; the figures beside it show it below its long-run norm.
Correction, November 2026
Atlanta Residential, February 2026: the Unemployment, U.S., for reference reading said above; the figures beside it show it below its long-run norm.
Correction, October 2026
The August 2026 snapshot said the committed classification moved to Correction on August 26. The record shows the displayed reading moved on August 26 while the committed reading was still four of seven daily samples toward Correction on August 27. It also omitted an earlier displayed Correction reading from about August 7 to 21, which reversed on August 23 when a stale input was replaced with current data. The snapshot is amended below; the original wording is preserved in the change log.
VI · Sources and vintage
Sources and vintage
| Row | Series / source |
|---|---|
| Real GDP growth | FRED GDPC1 (BEA NIPA 1.1.6); GDPCA for 1937; Census HSUS F-3 (Kendrick/Commerce real GNP, 1958 $) for 1929 |
| Industrial production | FRED INDPRO (Fed G.17) |
| Unemployment rate | FRED UNRATE (BLS); Census HSUS D-86 for 1929, 1937 |
| Employment growth | FRED PAYEMS (BLS CES); HSUS D-127 for 1929, 1937 |
| Personal saving rate | FRED PSAVERT, A072RC1Q156SBEA, A072RC1A156NBEA (BEA) |
| Real DPI per capita | FRED A229RX0, A229RX0Q048SBEA, A229RX0A048NBEA (BEA) |
| Consumer credit / income | FRED TOTALSL (Fed G.19) / DSPI (BEA); NBER Macrohistory M10092USM144NNBR for 1929, 1937 |
| Top 1% income share | Piketty-Saez TabFig2024.xlsx, Table A3, P99-100 incl. capital gains |
| Housing starts | FRED HOUST (Census); NBER Macrohistory M0261BUSM610NNBR (1945-1958), A0261AUSA610NNBR (1929, 1937) |
| Corporate profits / GDP (context) | FRED CPROFIT, A051RC1A027NBEA / GDP, GDPA (BEA) |
| Household debt / GDP | Fed Z.1 FL153165105.Q (FRED HHMSDODNS) + FL153166000.Q (FRED HCCSDODNS) / GDP; HSUS N 273 + NBER consumer credit for 1929, 1937 |
| Margin debt / GDP | FINRA Margin Statistics (debit balances) from 2000; Fed Z.1 FL663067005.Q 1948-1990; Fed Banking and Monetary Statistics 1914-1941 Tables 142-143 for 1929, 1937 |
| Gross federal debt / GDP | FRED GFDEBTN / GDP; GFDGDPA188S (OMB Hist. 7.1); Treasury FiscalData historical debt; BMS Table 148 |
| Debt held by public / GDP | FRED FYGFDPUN / GDP; FYPUGDA188S (OMB); BMS Table 149 |
| Federal budget balance / GDP | FRED MTSDS133FMS (Monthly Treasury Statement, 12-month sum); FYFSGDA188S (OMB) |
| Effective tariff rate | FRED B235RC1Q027SBEA / A255RC1Q027SBEA (BEA NIPA customs duties / goods imports); annual pair before 1960 |
| Fed credit / GDP (context) | NBER Macrohistory m14066 (1929-1960); Fed Z.1 FL713061103.Q + FL713061705.Q (1969-2000); FRED WRESCRT (H.4.1) from 2007 |
| Shiller CAPE, Dividend yield, Equity risk premium | Shiller ie_data.xls (file saved October 2026); GS10 (Fed H.15) |
| Corporate equities / GDP | FRED NCBEILQ027S (Z.1 nonfinancial corporate equities, market value) / GDP |
| Short rate / last Fed move | NBER m13009 (FRBNY discount rate) to 1953; FRED FEDFUNDS from 1957; DFF current; DFEDTAR / DFEDTARU / DFEDTARL target moves |
| Expansion length | NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee chronology |
Vintage. The "current" column is the latest published value of each series as of October 2026; each current value carries its own as-of month. Nothing here dates, predicts or implies a peak.
Providentia is Stoa's proprietary market-cycle engine. It reads the public record (the Federal Reserve's data library, the labor and commerce statistics, the Treasury, the exchanges' volatility and positioning data, the housing agencies and the listing portals), scores one hundred forty factors in eleven categories into nineteen composites, and classifies where the cycle stands in one of nine phases. For real estate it distills to twenty-six factors a professional can cite to a client in plain language: deal terms, affordability, carrying cost, credit, and Georgia against the states it competes with. The Record publishes its readings as dated snapshots, never live.
The Record's phase framework is its own. Its later phases draw on published work on fiscal dominance, credited in Foundations IV.4.
Citations. NBER Macrohistory Database; NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee; Piketty and Saez; FINRA Margin Statistics; Robert Shiller, online data.
The Cycle · The Record, The Practice's market publication
Educational, not professional advice. Nothing on this page is affiliated with or endorsed by its publisher.

